
Start with what the number counts
Before moving money between booking channels, ask whoever prepared the report to finish this sentence: this is the cost of acquiring one what? A reservation, a completed stay and a first-time customer need separate definitions.
Customer acquisition cost, or CAC, needs a clear definition of customer and the costs included. For this review, define a new customer as a lead booker completing their first stay at your property, and keep that rule consistent.
Cendyn's Hotel Digital Marketing Performance Index compares January–June 2025 with the same period in 2024 for Google's Performance Max for travel goals campaigns. The disclosed measure is advertising spend per attributed booking, not all acquisition costs per new guest; the vendor-reported change is not a target for your property.
Choose the question before the calculation
If you want to review advertising efficiency, start with advertising spend per booking credited to the campaign. If you want to compare distribution channels, assemble their agreed costs and follow the reservations through to completed stays.
Use a new-customer calculation only when your records can identify first-time bookers and the costs assigned to acquiring them. If new and returning customers cannot be separated reliably, label that view unavailable and report the booking-based measure instead.
Give each report a clear job
| Question | Suggested calculation | Keep this limit visible |
|---|---|---|
| What did the advertising buy? | Advertising spend ÷ confirmed reservations credited to that campaign | Does not establish how many customers were new or how many stayed. |
| What did a completed reservation cost to acquire? | Agreed channel acquisition costs ÷ completed reservations in the matched booking group | Includes repeat customers unless you deliberately separate them. |
| What did a new customer cost? | Acquisition costs assigned to verified new customers ÷ those customers completing a first stay | Use only when both new-customer status and the cost allocation are supportable. |
| What did the channel leave behind? | Collected stay revenue, after refunds, minus agreed acquisition, distribution and variable stay costs | This contribution view is not net profit if shared or fixed costs are omitted. |
Put the costs beside their source records
Ask finance and marketing to agree a cost list before ranking channels. Consider advertising, commissions, booking or transaction fees, and the agency or creative costs relevant to the comparison, using your own invoices and agreements.
Show shared expenses separately until you have a documented allocation rule. Do not split a mixed campaign between new and returning customers using a guessed percentage just to fill the table.
Keep discounts and refunds consistent with the revenue figure you use. If a discount has already reduced recorded revenue, do not subtract the same amount again as a separate cost.
Separate the booking channel from the marketing source
Keep a column for where the reservation was made and another for the marketing source credited with helping generate it. A website booking and a campaign-attributed booking can describe the same reservation, so they should not become two bookings in your total.
Use a reservation ID to connect records wherever your systems allow it. Record unmatched or duplicated entries for review, and agree which source supplies the final reservation count before discussing channel performance.
Build a channel comparison your team can maintain
Agree the comparison
Have the owner, finance lead and marketing lead choose the question, customer definition and cost categories. Write down whether the report follows bookings created during a period or stays completed during it, and keep the two views separate.
Collect the booking records
Ask reservations to export booking IDs, creation dates, stay dates, booking channels, amounts and current status. Include a reliable first-stay flag if one exists; otherwise leave new-customer status unknown.
Match the costs to the same group
Have finance attach invoices and fee records, with marketing explaining campaign reporting dates and credit rules. Label shared or unmatched expenses explicitly rather than hiding them inside a channel total.
Reconcile before ranking
Check cancellations, refunds, duplicate IDs and completed stays against the reservation system. If some bookings have not reached their stay dates, keep the result provisional instead of treating them as completed business.
Choose a limited next test
Ask the commercial lead to review the result alongside available rooms and the kind of stay each channel brought. Record the proposed budget change, evaluation period and outcome that would justify continuing it.
Keep a cheap booking in context
Before declaring a channel the winner, compare the room types, stay lengths and dates behind its result. Ask whether the apparent advantage is still useful for the inventory you need to sell next.
Review cancellations and contribution alongside the acquisition measure, using the same booking group. A low acquisition cost is useful information, but it does not answer every question about the value of those stays.
Know when the report cannot support a decision
If one channel includes all relevant fees and another includes advertising alone, repair the comparison before moving budget. If the reporting periods or booking groups differ, show separate results until you can align them.
Do not turn unknown customer status into a claim about new-customer growth. Your next useful task may be improving reservation records or cost allocation, with a named owner and a date to review the gap.
Bring these records to the next marketing meeting
Start with one reporting period, your reservation export and the related cost records. Ask your team to produce a booking-based view first, then add a new-customer view only where the evidence supports it.
Leave the meeting with a clear definition, a list of missing inputs and one decision the report can support. That gives the next budget discussion a firmer basis than comparing headline acquisition figures.
A useful channel-cost comparison states what you acquired, which costs you counted and what happened to the booking.
